Skip to Main Content
AI-generated illustration of an empty medical office waiting room with a row of walnut chairs with cream cushions against a navy wall, one chair in muted red pulled slightly out of line, late-afternoon light through window blinds and a potted plant at the left
CMS proposes 90-day verification of Medicare Advantage provider directories. Illustration created with AI image tools.

CMS Takes On MA Ghost Directories: A Florida Guide 2026

Consider a cardiologist in Fort Myers whose front desk fields the same call several times a week. A Medicare Advantage member found the practice in her plan’s online directory, booked a new-patient visit, and arrived to learn that the practice left that network two years ago. Somebody has to explain the out-of-network bill. The directory was the plan’s product, but the practice is the one standing in the room.

On October 16, CMS proposed the rule that is supposed to end that scene. The Contract Year 2028 Medicare Advantage and Part D proposed rule, CMS-4214-P, was published in the Federal Register on October 20 and takes comments until 5 p.m. Eastern on December 15, 2026. It implements the REAL Health Providers Act, which Congress folded into the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2026 in February. The rule aims at plans, not physicians. The work it creates, however, is going to show up in physician offices, and in Florida, where 57 percent of Medicare beneficiaries were in Medicare Advantage plans as of January, it will show up in nearly every one of them.

What CMS Proposed

The directory provisions sit in a new section 422.123. Starting with contract year 2028, every network-based Medicare Advantage plan would have to verify its directory information for each listed provider at least once every 90 days. Hospitals, intensive care services and ambulatory surgery settings would be checked once every 12 months. Plans could verify by phone or email, through provider attestations, through claims data, or by matching against NPPES and the national provider directory CMS is building. CMS notes that NPPES alone cannot confirm whether a physician is accepting new patients, so someone at the plan will still have to reach someone at the practice.

If a plan cannot verify a listing within the 90-day cycle, the directory must flag that physician with an indicator saying the information may not be up to date. Changes to the online directory would be due within 30 days, and a physician who has left the network would have to be removed within five business days.

Two further pieces matter more than the cadence. First, proposed section 422.123(b)(4) would require every plan to write a clause into every provider contract obligating the physician to maintain current and accurate directory information. Directory accuracy becomes a contractual duty of the practice, not only a regulatory duty of the plan. Second, each plan would have to run an annual accuracy audit on a random sample of its listings, report the resulting score to CMS, and, beginning with contract year 2029, display that score prominently in its own directory while CMS posts all scores in a machine-readable file. Mental health and substance use specialties would have to be included in every sample because their listings have been the least reliable.

The rule also carries a cost-sharing protection. A member who relies on an incorrect listing and ends up seeing an out-of-network physician would owe no more than the in-network cost-sharing amount. The statute places that obligation on the plan. How the plan then settles with the out-of-network physician is the part of the proposed text that Florida practices should read most carefully before December 15.

Why CMS Is Doing This

The agency’s own numbers make the case. Between June 2022 and June 2024, CMS reviewed the online directories of 142 Medicare Advantage organizations, covering 11,360 providers at 18,852 locations. In 44.29 percent of those location listings, reviewers found at least one error: a physician who did not see patients at the address, a wrong phone number, a physician who no longer accepted the plan, or information that could not be verified at all. Primary care, cardiology and oncology each posted deficiency rates of 45 percent or higher across all three review rounds. CMS had not published those results before this rule.

Outside reviews have been worse. A 2023 report from Senator Ron Wyden’s office called 120 listed mental health providers across 12 plans and found that more than 80 percent were ghosts. The HHS Office of Inspector General reached the same conclusion about behavioral health networks in October 2025, and added that physicians named low payment and administrative burden as the reasons they would not see plan members.

The plans will say, with some justification, that practices change addresses, phone systems and panel status without telling anyone, and that a 90-day verification cycle is an administrative cost CMS concedes it has not quantified. That is true. It is also the reason the burden is about to be pushed downstream.

What Changes for Florida Physicians

Florida has roughly three million Medicare Advantage members, one of the largest totals of any state, and a typical independent practice here participates in a long list of Medicare Advantage products across Humana, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Florida Blue, Devoted and the rest. Each of those plans will now need to confirm your address, phone number, specialty, panel status and location roster every 90 days. The office that ignores the verification emails will see its listing flagged as unverified, and patients comparing plans during open enrollment will read that flag as a reason to pick someone else.

The contract clause is the quieter change. Once directory accuracy is a term of your participation agreement, a stale listing is a contract breach, and a plan in a rate negotiation or a termination dispute has a new paragraph to point to. Practices that are already in the middle of the UnitedHealthcare network reorganization for 2027, or that lost patients when 51 Florida Medicare Advantage plans exited, should expect the new language to arrive in the next amendment packet.

The cost-sharing protection cuts both ways for the out-of-network physician. A patient who relied on a bad listing is protected from the balance, which is good for the patient and for the exam-room conversation. Whether the plan pays the physician a reasonable amount for that visit, or recoups the difference from a practice it still contracts with elsewhere, is not settled in the text I have read, and it is the question the Florida Medical Association and the specialty societies should press in their comment letters.

The rule would also require plans to disclose in the directory when a listed provider is under common ownership or control with the plan or its parent. In a state where Optum, Humana’s CenterWell and other plan-affiliated groups own a growing share of primary care, that label will appear beside your competitors’ names, and beside yours if you have sold.

What You Can Do

  1. Audit your own listings this month. Check address, phone, specialty, new-patient status and every listed location in each Medicare Advantage directory you participate in, fix errors through the plan portal, and keep a dated record of each request.
  2. Pick one source of truth. Assign one staff member to own NPPES, CAQH ProView and plan portal updates and to answer the 90-day verification requests when they start arriving in 2028.
  3. Read the next contract amendment before you sign it. Look for a directory-accuracy clause and ask what the remedy for a breach is. None of this constitutes legal advice, so have a health care attorney review any amendment that ties directory accuracy to termination or recoupment.
  4. Comment by December 15. The docket is CMS-2026-3533 on regulations.gov. Tell CMS what a 90-day verification cycle costs a three-physician office, and ask it to specify how plans must pay out-of-network physicians under the cost-sharing protection.
  5. Bring it to your county medical society and the FMA. The implementing rule is where the burden gets allocated, and the plans will be in the docket whether physicians are or not.

The Bigger Picture

Ghost directories have been documented for a decade, and every Medicare Advantage plan in Florida has had the data to fix its own listings for all of that time. It took an act of Congress to require them to try. The rule is a real improvement for patients, and physicians should say so. It is also a reminder that when a system fails, the correction tends to arrive as a new obligation for the people who did not build the system. The physicians who comment on the docket will shape how that obligation lands. The ones who do not will learn about it from a contract amendment.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Medicare Advantage provider directory rule CMS proposed in October 2026?

CMS-4214-P, published October 20, 2026, would require Medicare Advantage plans to verify provider directory information at least every 90 days beginning in contract year 2028, flag unverified listings, remove departed providers within five business days, report annual accuracy scores to CMS and display them starting in 2029. Comments are due December 15, 2026.

Does the rule require Florida physicians to do anything?

Not directly. The obligations fall on the plans. The proposed rule would, however, require every plan to add a contract clause obligating physicians to keep their directory information current and accurate, and plans will contact practices to verify listings each quarter.

What happens if a Medicare Advantage patient relies on a wrong directory listing in Florida?

Under the proposed rule, a member who relies on an incorrect listing and receives care from an out-of-network provider would owe no more than the in-network cost-sharing amount. The plan is responsible for that protection. How the plan settles with the out-of-network physician is a detail practices should review in the proposed text.

How inaccurate are Medicare Advantage directories?

CMS found at least one error in 44.29 percent of 18,852 location listings it reviewed across 142 Medicare Advantage organizations between 2022 and 2024. A 2023 Senate review found more than 80 percent of listed in-network mental health providers were not reachable or not taking patients.

How can a Florida physician comment on CMS-4214-P?

Submit comments through regulations.gov under docket CMS-2026-3533 by 5 p.m. Eastern on December 15, 2026, or through the Florida Medical Association and your specialty society, which will file their own letters.

This article was drafted with the assistance of AI writing tools, then reviewed, edited, and approved by Dr. Sean C. Orr, M.D., who holds full editorial responsibility for its content. The header illustration was created with AI image tools.

References

  1. CMS, “CMS Proposes Reforms to Strengthen Transparency and Affordability in Medicare Advantage and Part D,” press release, October 16, 2026. cms.gov
  2. CMS, “Medicare Program; Implementation of Sections 6219, 6220, and 6224 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026 (CMS-4214-P),” fact sheet, October 16, 2026. cms.gov
  3. Federal Register, “Medicare Program; Contract Year 2028 Policy and Technical Changes to the Medicare Advantage Program, Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit Program, Medicare Cost Plan Program, and Programs of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly,” 91 FR 66408, Document 2026-21420, October 20, 2026. federalregister.gov
  4. Becker’s Hospital Review, “CMS proposes public scores for Medicare Advantage provider directories, flat-fee limits for PBMs,” October 16, 2026. beckershospitalreview.com
  5. Fierce Healthcare, “CMS proposes MA ‘ghost network,’ PBM transparency requirements,” October 16, 2026. fiercehealthcare.com
  6. SBA Office of Advocacy, “CMS Proposes Policy and Technical Changes for Multiple Medicare Programs in 2028,” October 22, 2026. advocacy.sba.gov
  7. AMA, “A more accurate Medicare Advantage provider directory on the way,” March 11, 2026. ama-assn.org
  8. HHS Office of Inspector General, “Many Medicare Advantage and Medicaid Managed Care Plans Have Limited Behavioral Health Provider Networks and Inactive Providers,” OEI-02-23-00540, October 2025. oig.hhs.gov
  9. KFF, “Medicare Advantage in 2026: Enrollment Update and Key Trends,” June 5, 2026. kff.org
  10. healthinsurance.org, “Medicare in Florida,” citing CMS Medicare Monthly Enrollment data, January 2026. healthinsurance.org