By Sean Orr, M.D. | October 22, 2026 | Florida Doctor Magazine
Consider how a payment suspension actually arrives at a three-physician family practice in Ocala. The Medicare deposits stop first. A letter from the Medicare contractor follows a few days later, saying that the practice’s claims are under review on a credible allegation of fraud, that the practice may submit a written rebuttal, and that the suspension stays in place while the review runs. Payroll does not wait for the review. If the suspension is lifted months later with no finding against the practice, the withheld money is released as a lump sum, and the regulation makes no provision for interest on it.
That sequence is about to become more common. On October 15, Deputy CMS Administrator Kimberly Brandt told the ADAPT conference in Santa Fe that she hopes the number of provider payment suspensions “will quadruple over the course of the next six months.” The day before, the Secretary of Health and Human Services published a Federal Register notice handing CMS its own authority to exclude physicians from Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE and every other federal health program. And in Florida, the Agency for Health Care Administration has terminated more than 220 Medicaid providers this year and ordered every active Medicaid provider to revalidate. Three enforcement engines are accelerating at once.
What Changed This Week
The Federal Register notice is short. Published October 14 and effective immediately, it delegates the Secretary’s permissive exclusion authority under section 1128(b) of the Social Security Act to the CMS Administrator. Until this week that power belonged to the Office of Inspector General, which keeps it under a 1988 delegation, so two agencies now hold co-equal discretion to exclude a physician for the same conduct. Permissive exclusion covers the lesser offenses: a health care misdemeanor, a kickback arrangement, a misrepresentation to the agency, an ownership tie to someone already excluded. Mandatory exclusion for felony convictions stays with OIG. HHS says CMS “is uniquely positioned to investigate, identify, and develop the evidentiary basis” for these determinations.
Brandt’s remarks the next day put the delegation in context. CMS reported $41.9 billion in anti-fraud savings for fiscal year 2025, up 59 percent. A “Medicaid War Room” launched in April has stopped $342 million in improper payments and sent 124 notices of intent to exclude. A screening algorithm compares every newly enrolled provider against the agency’s existing population and places suspicious entrants on a six-month watchlist; CMS says it has removed about 67 percent of the providers on that list. Machine-learning pilots in Indiana and five other states flag upcoding, phantom services and geographic anomalies before a Medicaid claim pays, with the stated goal of “a national, standardized, continuously improving platform.”
Brandt was candid about the limits in the same speech. Of WISeR, the AI-supported prior authorization test running in six states since January, she said, “There are a lot of things about WISeR that are not working.” That is an admission that the agency has already deployed one algorithm against clinicians that did not work as intended, and it now plans to deploy more of them, faster, with a suspension as the output rather than a denial.
The Florida Layer
Florida physicians face this from two directions. The state’s Medicaid Integrity Initiative, announced June 12 and updated by Governor DeSantis and AHCA Secretary Shevaun Harris at an October 6 press conference, has terminated more than 220 providers who billed more than $230 million in 2025, placed more than 250 on payment restriction or suspension, and made more than 150 referrals to the Attorney General. AHCA is piloting an identity-screening vendor, SentiLink, and every active Florida Medicaid provider, physicians included, must revalidate credentials and identity or be removed. CMS, for its part, sent Florida one of only four state program-integrity inquiry letters this year, alongside California, Maine and New York. Florida is not an observer in this campaign. It is one of the places the campaign is aimed.
The case for all of this is real. Florida paid about $6.57 billion for applied behavior analysis services from 2023 through 2025, nearly four times any other state’s Medicaid program, and AHCA’s investigators found providers billing more than 24 hours of service in a single day. Stolen Medicaid identification numbers were used to submit claims the named physician never saw. Honest physicians are the ones whose names get borrowed and whose fee schedules get squeezed to pay for what the thieves took, and Harris is right that “claims do not submit themselves.”
The problem is the instrument. A payment suspension under 42 CFR 405.372 can be imposed without prior notice when CMS decides that notice would harm the trust funds, it lasts 180 days and can be extended another 180, and when it rests on a credible allegation of fraud the time limits do not apply at all. The physician’s remedy is a written rebuttal, not a hearing. Exclusion is worse: it ends a career in federally funded medicine, and now two agencies can initiate it. Health care lawyers at Reed Smith noted this week that CMS has no enforcement division or litigators of its own, and that a physician who settled with OIG under a corporate integrity agreement could still face a CMS exclusion for the same facts, because CMS was never a party to that agreement. None of those questions has an answer yet. A quadrupled suspension count will produce the answers through litigation, with physicians as the test cases.
What Florida Physicians Should Do Now
-
Confirm your Florida Medicaid revalidation status this week. Check every enrolled location and every rendering and billing NPI in the group, and complete anything outstanding. A removal cascades into every managed care plan you participate in.
-
Reconcile what PECOS and NPPES say about you against what is true. Addresses, reassignments, managing employees and ownership percentages are the fields the screening algorithm compares, and a stale record reads the same as a false one to a machine.
-
Pull your own claims data before someone else does. Run a utilization report by code and rendering provider for the last 24 months against the norms for your specialty. If you are an outlier on a code, know why, and write the reason in a dated memo. An outlier with a documented clinical explanation is a conversation; an outlier without one is a suspension.
-
Decide today who opens the letter. A suspension notice gives a short rebuttal window. Name the person in your office who screens mail from Medicare contractors, AHCA and the Unified Program Integrity Contractor, and give that person the name of a health care attorney to call the same day. None of this constitutes legal advice, so have your own counsel review the response plan before you need it.
-
Hold three months of operating cash, or secure the line of credit that would stand in for it. A suspension stops the money and keeps the obligations, and a government review does not move at the speed of a payroll.
-
Report the misuse of your identity. If a claim appears under your NPI for a patient you did not treat, file with the Medicare contractor and AHCA’s Medicaid Program Integrity office, keep the confirmation, and tell the Florida Medical Association, so the data it brings to the Legislature includes how often honest physicians are the victims of the fraud being counted against them.
The Bigger Picture
Organized medicine has asked for program integrity for years, because every dollar stolen from Medicare comes out of the conversion factor. What it has not asked for is a system in which the first contact between a physician and an enforcer is a stopped deposit and the only process is a letter. The Florida Medical Association and the specialty societies have a short window to shape how CMS and AHCA use these tools before the tools define the relationship. The asks are concrete: a prior-notice default for physicians with no history of adverse action, published rebuttal timelines, a human clinical reviewer on every algorithmic referral, interest on money withheld from physicians later cleared, and a standing channel to report identity theft of an NPI. Brandt said provider feedback is a signal her agency should monitor. Florida physicians should make sure the signal is loud.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Medicare payment suspension and how long can it last?
Under 42 CFR 405.371 and 405.372, CMS or its contractor can withhold some or all Medicare payments while it investigates a suspected overpayment or a credible allegation of fraud. A suspension generally lasts 180 days and can be extended once for up to 180 more. When it is based on a credible allegation of fraud, those time limits do not apply, and the suspension ends when the investigation is resolved.
Can CMS now exclude a Florida physician from Medicare without OIG?
Yes. A Statement of Delegation of Authority published in the Federal Register on October 14, 2026, gives the CMS Administrator the Secretary’s permissive exclusion authority under section 1128(b) of the Social Security Act, effective immediately. OIG keeps its own 1988 delegation, so both agencies can now pursue permissive exclusions. Mandatory exclusions for felony convictions remain with OIG.
Do Florida physicians have to revalidate their Medicaid enrollment in 2026?
Yes. AHCA’s Medicaid Integrity Initiative requires all active Florida Medicaid providers to revalidate their credentials and identity, and the agency has said providers who do not comply will be removed from the program. Check the status of every enrolled location and NPI in the Florida Medicaid provider portal and complete anything outstanding.
What should I do if I receive a notice of payment suspension?
Read the rebuttal deadline first and calendar it, then contact a health care attorney the same day. Gather the medical records and claims data the notice references and submit a written rebuttal within the stated period. A suspension is not an appealable initial determination, so the rebuttal is the main opportunity to have it lifted. This is general information and not legal advice.
Is Florida a target of the federal Medicaid fraud crackdown?
Florida received one of four state program-integrity inquiry letters from CMS in 2026, with questions about durable medical equipment, telemedicine and pharmacy billing. Separately, the state’s own AHCA has terminated more than 220 Medicaid providers in 2026 and placed more than 250 on payment restriction or suspension.
This article was drafted with the assistance of AI writing tools, then reviewed, edited, and approved by Dr. Sean C. Orr, M.D., who holds full editorial responsibility for its content. The header illustration was created with AI image tools.
References
- Nextgov/FCW, “CMS hopes to quadruple provider suspensions over next six months, official says,” October 15, 2026. nextgov.com
- Becker’s Hospital Review, “CMS wants to quadruple provider suspensions in 6 months,” October 16, 2026. beckershospitalreview.com
- Federal Register, “Statement of Delegation of Authority,” 91 FR 65219, Document 2026-21001, October 14, 2026. federalregister.gov
- AHA News, “CMS delegated exclusion authorities for Medicare, Medicaid,” October 14, 2026. aha.org
- Reed Smith, Health Industry Washington Watch, “Delegation of permissive Medicare and Medicaid exclusion authority raises questions and may further politicize fraud enforcement,” October 15, 2026. reedsmith.com
- Ermer & Suter PLLC, “Tuesday Report,” October 20, 2026 (WISeR remarks and CMS suspension target). ermersuter.com
- News4Jax, “‘Claims do not submit themselves’: Florida cracks down on Medicaid fraud, projects $1B in savings,” October 6, 2026. news4jax.com
- Executive Office of the Governor, “Governor Ron DeSantis Announces Medicaid Integrity Initiative to Crack Down on Fraud,” June 12, 2026. flgov.com
- KFF, “What to Know About Recent Federal Actions Involving State Medicaid Program Integrity,” June 9, 2026 (updated July 16, 2026). kff.org
- 42 CFR 405.372, “Proceeding for suspension of payment.” law.cornell.edu






Leave a Reply